Why this Vegas Golden Knights and New York Rangers trade does (and doesn't) work

Is it worth sacrificing an "Original Misfit" for another?

The one thing that Vegas Golden Knight fans must ask themselves regarding Reilly Smith in this scenario is the trade method. Is it worth getting a year rental and sacrificing another "Original Misfit" to get him? Would this be something that Kelly McCrimmon would consider, even if a first-round pick was involved?

Some things would benefit the Golden Knights if they traded with the New York Rangers. For one, they get additional draft capital and a younger blue-liner while the Rangers get a puck-moving defenseman. There's also the fan nostalgia that stands out, bringing back memories of the two Stanley Cup Final runs (and championship).

However, there's also trading Theodore to achieve that nostalgia that's the problem. Right now, the blue-liner is superior to the Rangers winger offensively, especially since he does more at a younger age. Historically, McCrimmon hasn't shied away from trading former first-round draft picks, with Zach Dean and David Edstrom being shining examples. Add the cap space stalemate and there isn't much reason regarding why McCrimmon would trade for a "Misfit".