Skip to main content

After yet another poor showing, it should be the beginning of the end for the Carter Hart experiment

The Golden Knights would do well to avoid the sunk-cost fallacy with their unreliable goaltender
ByRobert Lazar
Hart had an awful game against the lowly Canucks on Sunday night.
Hart had an awful game against the lowly Canucks on Sunday night. | Zak Krill/GettyImages

Entering this season, one question loomed big in Golden Knights fans' minds: what would the team do regarding goaltending? After all, seemingly every option trotted out last year was varying degrees of bad, with none of last year's five goaltenders posting better than an .893 save percentage. However, with the lack of a trade for Connor Hellebuyck, and his playoff performance pre-Finals, the answer seemed somewhat clear: it would be Carter Hart until proven otherwise.

Needless to say, that bet has not paid off. A month and a half into the season, the Golden Knights' controversial goaltender has been anything but a reliable starter, mostly farming wins off of bad teams while faltering against stronger competition. After a disaster of a game against the last-place Vancouver Canucks, however, the answers should be clear: Adin Hill should be the starter going forward, and Carter Hart should not be on this roster next season.

I, for one, am done with Hart

I'll openly admit that I do not like Carter Hart. Regardless of the circumstances of his signing, this team is enough of a villain in most fans' eyes, and I would have much rather not signed someone with his sort of personal baggage. But now, even the most ardent VGK fans can't say he's been worth the media circus.

Let's look at just this year, and ignore his inconsistency last season, as well as his historically awful Stanley Cup Finals. Hart has six wins on the year; seems great, right? That is, until, you look at who they've been against. The only legitimately "good" team he's beaten was the Utah Mammoth a few nights ago, and they were down multiple key players in that one, with Dylan Guenther and Nick Schmaltz headlining their injuries before and during the game. He also accounts for four of our six regulation losses, in all of which he's allowed at least four goals. I mean, seriously just look at this goal from John Carlson in our 6-2 loss to Tampa Bay last month:

Hart practically had a lifetime to get across that crease, but instead he froze up and let John Carlson pounce on his own rebound into a wide-open net. Just... yikes.

The advanced stats back me up here as well. Among 77 goaltenders to have featured in a game this year, Hart ranks 48th in goals saved above expected, with a -1.1 on the season. Doesn't seem too awful, until you realize it's worse than the likes of Philipp Grubauer and Nico Daws, and only marginally better than Leevi Merilainen, the man who thoroughly outdueled Hart on Sunday night. All of that has made for him posting an .888 save percentage as of the time of this article, tied for 34th among 65 goalies with 5+ games and 14th of 24 goaltenders with his 12+ games. Behind this defense, being below-average like that is simply is not acceptable.

But wait - what do we do instead?

Well, I'm glad you asked!

By contrast, Adin Hill has had nothing short of a full renaissance this year, rounding back into form with a .908 SV% and 2.47 GAA in ten games. By contrast, his 3.6 GSAx sit 20th in the league, and his numbers get even better if you exclude his one disaster game against the Blues several weeks ago. In addition, Carl Lindbom is back to his winning ways in the AHL, returning from a injury with a 31-save shutout of the San Diego Gulls to improve to a .939 and 1.43 on the season. Heck, even his tandem partner Cameron Whitehead has been electric, posting a 1.68 and .948 himself. Any of these are better options at this point, and given Hill is slated to start against the powerhouse Dallas Stars tonight, it seems head coach Ryan Craig agrees.

Hart is a pending free agent this year, coming up on the end of his two-year deal. He will almost certainly demand a starter's salary, given his playoff performance last year and "ceiling." Vegas absolutely cannot give it to him, nor should they trade Adin Hill to do so. With any luck, we're rid of this wildly inconsistent, personally questionable goaltender by this time next year, and we start handing the keys to our young studs instead.

Add us as a preferred source on Google